On First-Order Fragments for Mazurkiewicz Traces

Issue title: Half a Century of Inspirational Research: Honoring the Scientific Influence of Antoni Mazurkiewicz

Article type: Research Article

Authors: Diekert, Volker | Horsch, Martin | Kufleitner, Manfred

Affiliations: Institut für Formale Methoden der Informatik, FMI, Universität Stuttgart, Universitätsstraße 38 70569 Stuttgart, Germany. E-mail: {diekert,kufleitner}@fmi.uni-stuttgart.de

Abstract: Mazurkiewicz traces form a model for concurrency. Temporal logic and first-order logic are important tools in order to deal with the abstract behavior of such systems. Since typical properties can be described by rather simple logical formulas one is interested in logical fragments. One focus of this paper is unary temporal logic and first-order logic in two variables. Over words, this corresponds to the variety of finite monoids calledDA. However, overMazurkiewicz traces it is crucial whether traces are given as dependence graphs or as partial orders (over words these notions coincide). The main technical contribution is a generalization of important characterizations of DA from words to dependence graphs, whereas the use of partial orders leads to strictly larger classes. As a consequence we can decide whether a first-order formula over dependence graphs is equivalent to a first-order formula in two variables. The corresponding result for partial orders is not known. This difference between dependence graphs and partial orders also affects the complexity of the satisfiability problems for the fragments under consideration: for first-order formulas in two variables we prove an NEXPTIME upper bound, whereas the corresponding problem for partial orders leads to EXPSPACE. Furthermore, we give several separation results for the alternation hierarchy for first-order logic. It turns out that even for those levels at which one can express the partial order relation in terms of dependence graphs, the fragments over partial orders have more expressive power.

Keywords: Mazurkiewicz traces, temporal logic, first-order logic, Ehrenfeucht-Fraïssé games

Journal: Fundamenta Informaticae, vol. 80, no. 1-3, pp. 1-29, 2007