International Group for Indigenous Health Measurement: Recommendations for best practice for estimation of Indigenous mortality
Abstract
AIM:
To provide a best practice guide on Indigenous mortality reporting based on recommendations from the International Group for Indigenous Health Measurement.
METHOD:
A workshop of the International Group for Indigenous Health Measurement was held in Montreal in 2013 during which best practices in determining Indigenous mortality were discussed. A subsequent discussion paper and draft recommendations were further refined at a meeting in Vancouver in 2014. A working group finalized this best practice guide in follow-up to the two meetings.
OUTCOME:
Ten final recommendations are made regarding identification, community engagement and ownership, data linkage, uncertainty in official statistics and a timeline for implementation. In this paper we review and discuss these recommendations drawing on examples of best practice in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States of America and highlighting some shortcomings in the current practices of official statistical agencies.
References
[1] | Freemantle J., , Ring I., , Solomon T.G.A., , Gachupin F.C., , Smylie J., , Cutler T.L. et al., Indigenous mortality (revealed): The invisible illuminated, Am J Public Health 105: (4) ((2015) ), 644. doi: 10.2105/ajph.2014.301994. |
[2] | Blakely T., , Soeberg M., , Carter K., , Costilla R., , Atkinson J., and Sarfati D., Bias in relative survival methods when using incorrect life-tables: Lung and bladder cancer by smoking status and ethnicity in New Zealand, International Journal of Cancer 131: (6) ((2012) ), E974. doi: 10.1002/ijc.27531. |
[3] | Smylie J., and Anderson M., Understanding the health of Indigenous Peoples in Canada: Key methodological and conceptual challenges, CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 175: (6) ((2006) ), 602. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.060940. |
[4] | Madden R., , Axelsson P., , Kukutai T., , Griffiths K., , Mienna C.S., , Brown N. et al., Statistics on Indigenous Peoples: International Effort Needed, Statistical Journal of the IAOS 32: (1) ((2016) ), 5. doi: 10.3233/SJI-160975. |
[5] | United Nations. The Principles and Recommendations for a Vital Statistics System, Revision 2, New York: United Nations, (2001) 92-1-161439-2. |
[6] | United Nations General Assembly, Fundamental Principles of Official Statistics, UN, 2014. |
[7] | United Nations General Assembly. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Adopted by the General Assembly on 13 September 2007, UN, (2008) . |
[8] | Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, Comparing life expectancy of indigenous people in Australia, New Zealand, Canda and the United States: conceptual, methodological and data issues, Canberra: AIHW, (2011) . |
[9] | Smylie J., and Firestone M., Back to the basics: Identifying and addressing underlying challenges in achieving high quality and relevant health statistics for indigenous populations in Canada, Statistical Journal of the IAOS 31: (1) ((2015) ), 67. doi: 10.3233/SJI-150864. |
[10] | Elias B., Moving beyond the historical quagmire of measuring infant mortality for the First Nations population in Canada, Social Science & Medicine 123: ((2014) ), 125. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2014.10.056. |
[11] | Elias B., , Busby K., and Martens P., One little too little: counting Canada's indigenous people for improved health reporting, Social Science & Medicine 138: ((2015) ), 179. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.06.014. |
[12] | Hill S., , Sarfati D., , Robson B., and Blakely T., Indigenous inequalities in cancer: What role for health care? ANZ journal of surgery, Surgery 83: (1-2) ((2013) ), 36. doi: 10.1111/ans.12041. |
[13] | Axelsson P., Abandoning ``the other'': Statistical enumeration of Swedish Sami 1700 to 1945 and beyond, Berichte Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte 33: (3) ((2010) ), 263. doi: 10.1002/bewi.201001469. |
[14] | Harwell T.S., , Hansen D., , Moore K.R., , Jeanotte D., , Gohdes D., and Helgerson S.D., Accuracy of race coding on American Indian death certificates Montana 1996-1998, Public Health Reports 117: (1) ((2002) ), 44. |
[15] | Blakely T., , Atkinson J., and Fawcett J., Ethnic counts on mortality and census data (mostly) agree for 2001-2004: New Zealand Census-Mortality Study update, New Zealand Medical Journal 121: (1281) ((2008) ), 58. |
[16] | Statistics New Zealand. Understanding and working with ethnicity data: A technical paper, Wellington: Statistics New Zealand, (2005) . |
[17] | Ministry of Health. Ethnicity data protocols for the health and disability sector, Ministry of Health Wellington, New Zealand, (2004) . |
[18] | Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Recent developments in the collection of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health and welfare statistics 2005 Canberra: AIHW & ABS, (2006) . |
[19] | Gracey M., and King M., Indigenous health part 1: Determinants and disease patterns, Lancet 374: (9683) ((2009) ), 65. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60914-4. |
[20] | King M., , Smith A., and Gracey M., Indigenous health part 2: The underlying causes of the health gap, Lancet 374: (9683) ((2009) ), 76. |
[21] | Barnes T., , Smith L., , Zhao Y., and Guthridge S., A comparative analysis of indirect methodologies for estimating Indigenous life expectancy, Darwin: School for Social and Policy Research, Charles Darwin University, (2008) . |
[22] | Madden R., , Tickle L., , Pulver L.J., and Ring I., Estimating Indigenous life expectancy: Pitfalls with consequences, Journal of Population Research 29: (3) ((2012) ), 269. doi: 10.1007/s12546-012-9085-6. |
[23] | Statistics Canada, Projections of Aboriginal populations, Canada, Provinces and Territories, 2001-2007. Ministry of Industry (2007) Ottawa: No. 91-547-XIE. |
[24] | Statistics Canada, Mortality of Métis and Registered Indian adults in Canada: An 11-year follow-up study, Ottawa: Ministry of Industry (2009) Ottawa: No. 82-003-XPE. |
[25] | Statistics Canada, Mortality rates among children and teenagers living in Inuit Nunangat, 1994 to 2008, Ottawa: Ministry of Industry, (2012) , Ottawa: No. 82-003-XPE. |
[26] | Statistics Canada, Health Profile, (2013) [cited 2015 15 Dec]. Available from: http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/health-sante/82-228/index.cfm?Lang=E. |
[27] | Statistics New Zealand, New Zealand Period Life Tables: 2012-14 Wellington: Statistics New Zealand, (2015) [cited 2015 22 Dec]. Available from: http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/health/life_expectancy/NZLifeTables_HOTP12-14/Data%20Quality.aspx. |
[28] | Statistics New Zealand, Deaths Wellington: Statistics New Zealand, (2015) [cited 2106 25 Mar]. Available from: http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/population/deaths.aspx. |
[29] | Arias E., editor Towards the next generation of record linkage studies to advance data quality assessment of civil registrations in low and middle-income coutries, IUSSP-PAA-WBG Meeting on CRVS & Record Linkage; (2016) ; Washington DC. |
[30] | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Classification of American Indian race on birth and infant death certificates - California and Montana, MMWR Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 42: (12) ((1993) ), 220. |
[31] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, Registered Indigenous Deaths 2008 [cited 2015 8 Sept]. Available from: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/0/23E5413F51E806DDCA2576780025 B0C9?opendocument. |
[32] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, Life Tables for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians. Canberra: ABS, 2013 3302.0.55.003. |
[33] | Office of the Prime Minister, Minister of Innovation, Science and Economic Development Mandate Letter Ottawa, Canada 2015 [cited 2015 25 Nov]. Available from: http://pm.gc.ca/eng/minister-innovation-science-and-economic-development-mandate-letter. |
[34] | Ministry of Health, editor, Tatau Kahukura: Maori Health Chart Book, 3 ed. Wellington: Ministry of Health; 2015. |
[35] | Arias E., , Schauman W.S., , Eschbach K., , Sorlie P.D., and Backlund E., The validity of race and Hispanic origin reporting on death certificates in the United States, Vital and Health Statistics Series 2, Data Evaluation and Methods Research (148) ((2008) ), 1. |
[36] | Hahn R.A., , Truman B.I., and Barker N.D., Identifying ancestry: The reliability of ancestral identification in the United States by self proxy interviewer and funeral director, Epidemiology ((1996) ), 75. |
[37] | Hahn R.A., , Wetterhall S.F., , Gay G.A., , Harshbarger D.S., , Burnett C.A., , Parrish R.G. et al., The recording of demographic information on death certificates: A national survey of funeral directors, Public Health Reports 117: (1) ((2002) ), 37. |
[38] | Ioannou G.N., , Chapko M.K., and Dominitz J.A., Predictors of colorectal cancer screening participation in the United States, The American Journal of Gastroenterology 98: (9) ((2003) ), 2082. |
[39] | Kwong S., , Perkins C., , Snipes K., and Wright W., Improving American Indian cancer data in the California cancer registry by linkage with the Indian Health Service, J Registry Manage 25: (1) ((1998) ), 17. |
[40] | Mettlin C.J., , Menck H.R., , Winchester D.P., and Murphy G.P., A comparison of breast colorectal lung and prostate cancers reported to the national cancer data base and the surveillance epidemiology and end results program, Cancer 79: (10) ((1997) ), 2052. |
[41] | Noymer A., , Penner A.M., and Saperstein A., Cause of death affects racial classification on death certificates, PLoS One 6: (1) ((2011) ), e15812. |
[42] | Partin M.R., , Rith-Najarian S.J., , Slater J.S., , Korn J.E., , Cobb N., and Soler J.T., Improving cancer incidence estimates for American Indians in Minnesota, American Journal of Public Health 89: (11) ((1999) ), 1673. |
[43] | Poe G.S., , Powell-Griner E., , McLaughlin J.K., , Placek P.J., , Thompson G.B., and Robinson K., Comparability of the death certificate and the 1986 National Mortality Followback Survey, 1993. |
[44] | Puukka E., , Stehr-Green P., and Becker T.M., Measuring the health status gap for American Indians/Alaska Natives: Getting closer to the truth, American Journal of Public Health 95: (5) ((2005) ), 838. |
[45] | Rosenberg H.M., , Maurer J.D., , Sorlie P.D., , Johnson N.J., , MacDorman M.F., , Hoyert D.L. et al., Quality of death rates by race and Hispanic origin: A summary of current research 1999, Vital and Health Statistics Series 2, Data Evaluation and Methods Research (128) ((1999) ), 1. |
[46] | Stehr-Green P., , Bettles J., and Robertson L.D., Effect of racial/ethnic misclassification of American Indians and Alaskan Natives on Washington State death certificates 1989-1997, American Journal of Public Health 92: (3) ((2002) ), 443. |
[47] | Swan J., and Edwards B.K., Cancer rates among American Indians and Alaska Natives, Cancer 98: (6) ((2003) ), 1262. |
[48] | Jim M.A., , Arias E., , Seneca D.S., , Hoopes M.J., , Jim C.C., , Johnson N.J. et al., Racial misclassification of American Indians and Alaska Natives by Indian Health Service contract health service delivery area, American Journal of Public Health 104: (S3) ((2014) ), S295. |
[49] | Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. National best practice guidelines for collecting Indigenous status in health data sets. Canberra: AIHW, (2010) . |
[50] | Smylie J., , Firestone M., , Cochran L., , Prince C., , Maracle S., , Morley M. et al., Our Health Counts (2011) [cited 2016 15 Mar]. Available from: http://www.ourhealthcounts.ca/images/PDF/OHC-Report-Hamilton-ON.pdf. |
[51] | Firestone M., , Smylie J., , Maracle S., , Spiller M., and O'Campo P., Unmasking health determinants and health outcomes for urban First Nations using respondent-driven sampling, BMJ Open 4: (e004978) ((2014) ). doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2014-004978. |
[52] | Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, National Advisory Group on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Information and Data (NAGATSIHID) (2015) [cited 2015 27 Aug]. Available from: http://www.aihw.gov.au/nagatsihid/. |
[53] | First Nations Health Authority, British Columbia Ministry of Health, Health Canada, Tripartite Data Quality and Sharing Agreement, (2012) . |
[54] | Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Cheifs of Ontario (2016) [cited 2016 15 Mar]. Available from: http://www.ices. on.ca/Research/Collaborations-Partnerships/Chiefs%20of% 20Ontario. |
[55] | The First Nations Information Governance Centre, First Nations Regional Health Survey: The First Nations Information Governance Centre; (2016) [cited 2016 16 Mar]. Available from: http://fnigc.ca/our-work/regional-health-survey/about-rhs.html. |
[56] | Health (Cervical Screening (Kaitiaki)) Regulations 1995, Stat. SR 1995/29 (27 February 1995, 1995). |
[57] | Ministry of Health, Litmus Limited, The Centre for Public Health Research. Interim Evaluation Report of the Bowel Screening Pilot Screening Round One: Ministry of Health; (2015) [cited 2015 20 Jun]. Available from: http://www.health.govt.nz/system/files/documents/publications/interim-evaluation-report-bowel-screening-pilot-jun15.pdf. |
[58] | Native American Community Development Institute, (2015) [cited 2016 16 Mar]. Available from: http://www.nacdi.org/. |
[59] | Community Engagement Center, Native American Engagement: Pitzer College; (2015) [cited 2016 16 Mar]. Available from: http://pitweb.pitzer.edu/cec/native-American-engagement/. |
[60] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, ABS establishes Round Table on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Statistics Canberra: ABS; (2013) [cited 2015 27 Aug]. Available from: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/products/ACBECE9AD3F3BF D0CA257B6B00236761?OpenDocument. |
[61] | Statistics Canada, Aboriginal Children's Survey, 2006: Concepts and Methods Guide (2006) [cited 2016 16 Mar]. Available from: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/89-634-x/89-634-x2008006-eng.htm. |
[62] | Taylor L.K., , Bentley J., , Hunt J., , Madden R., , McKeown S., , Brandt P. et al., Enhanced reporting of deaths among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples using linked administrative health datasets, BMC Med Res Methodol 12: ((2012) ), 91. doi: 10.1186/1471-2288-12-91. |
[63] | Phillips B., , Morrell S., , Taylor R., and Daniels J., A review of life expectancy and infant mortality estimations for Australian Aboriginal people, BMC Public Health 14: ((2014) ), 1. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-1. |
[64] | Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, An enhanced mortality database for estimating Indigenous life expectancy: A feasibility study. Canberra, (2012) . |
[65] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, Death Registrations to Census Linkage Project - Methodology and Quality Assessment Australia 2011-2012, Canberra: ABS, (2013) . |
[66] | Ajwani S., , Blakely T., , Robson B., , Atkinson J., and Kiro C., Unlocking the numerator-denominator bias III: Adjustment ratios by ethnicity for 1981-1999 mortality data, The New Zealand Census-mortality Study New Zealand Medical Journal 116: (1175) ((2003) ), U456. |
[67] | Statistics New Zealand, Linking methodology used by Statistics New Zealand in the Integrated Data Infrastructure project (2014) [cited 2016 29 Feb]. Available from: http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/snapshots-of-nz/integrated-data-infrastructure/linking-methodology-statsnz-idi.aspx. |
[68] | Statistics Canada, Avoidable mortality among First Nations adults in Canada: A cohort analysis, Ottawa: Ministry of Industry (2015) Ottawa: No. 82-003-XPE. |
[69] | Liebler C.A., , Rastogi S., , Fernandez L.E., , Noon J.M., and Ennis S.R., America's churning races: race and ethnic response changes between census 2000 and the 2010 census, Washington DC: Center For Administrative Records Research and Applications, (2014) . |
[70] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, Estimates and Projections, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians Canberra: ABS, (2014) . |
[71] | Coleman C., , Fortune N., , Lee V., , Kalinda G., and Madden R., Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Life Expectancy and Mortality Trend Reporting: Sydney Centre for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Statistics; (2015) [cited 2016 16 Mar]. Available from: http://sydney.edu.au/health-sciences/scatsis/docs/AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderLifeExpectancyandMortalityReporting.pdf. |
[72] | Statistics New Zealand, Māori Population Estimates: At June 2015 - tables: New Zealand Government; (2015) [cited 2015 15 Dec]. Available from: http://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/population/estimates_and_projections/MaoriPopulationEstimates_HOTPAtJun15.aspx. |
[73] | Passel J.S., The growing American Indian population 1960-1990: beyond demography, Population Research and Policy Review 16: (1-2) ((1997) ), 11. |
[74] | Statistics Canada, Population Projections by Aboriginal Identity in Canada, 2006 to 2031 (2015) [cited 2016 17 Mar]. Available from: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/91-552-x/91-552-x2011001-eng.htm. |
[75] | United Nations, Manual X: indirect techniques for demographic estimation: a collaboration of the Population Division of the Department of International Economic and Social Affairs of the United Nations Secretariat with the Committee on Population and Demography of the National Research Council, United States National Academy of Sciences. New York: United Nations; (1983) . |
[76] | Australian Bureau of Statistics, Discussion Paper: Assessment of Methods for Developing Life Tables for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians, (2006) . |
[77] | Council of Australian Governments. National Indigenous Reform Agreement (Closing The Gap). Canberra (AUST): COAG, (2012) . |
