Predictors of Survival Outcomes in Non-Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma in Latin America and Spain: A Multicentric Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is one of the most lethal urological malignancies. About one-third of cases will have metastasis at presentation, and about 20%–50% will progress to metastatic disease despite surgical treatment [1–3]. Prognostic factors have been mainly described in series from North America and Europe, which have ethnic origins distinct from those of the Latin American population. In 2019, the American Cancer Society estimated 73,820 new cases of RCC and 14,770 deaths in the USA [4].

Latin America (LA) is a large developing area with people of multiracial and multicultural backgrounds, consisting of indigenous natives, European and Asian immigrants, and Africans. The number of new cases of RCC has risen both in the USA and LA, with a higher proportion of smaller lesions [5, 6]. Mortality has been stabilized with a slight decrease in recent years, particularly in developed countries. However, mortality is still rising in many developing areas [7, 8]. According to GLOBOCAN/IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer), the highest mortality rates adjusted for age in LA occur in Uruguay, Argentina, and Chile (7.3, 5.1, and 4.6 deaths/100,000 people in 2016, respectively) [9].

The Latin American Renal Cancer Group (LARCG) is a multi-institutional, non-profit group whose database consists of data collected from 28 centers in Latin America and Spain [10]. We aim to describe a large cohort of non-metastatic RCC cases in our database and identify the demographic, clinical, and pathological prognostic factors for overall and cancer-specific survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

RESULTS

We analyzed cases from eight countries operated between 1980 and 2016, counting 5,670 patients with no metastases at presentation. Among them, 33.1% (1,878 cases) were from Argentina, 18.9% (1,073 cases) from Brazil, 18.5% (1,050 cases) from Spain, and the others were from Chile (558 cases), Uruguay (458 cases), Mexico (274 cases), Peru (338 cases), and Bolivia (41 cases). For the survival analysis, we excluded 1,162 cases due to lack of follow-up data. A total of 4,508 patients met our inclusion criteria.

The follow-up time was 20 months ranged from 0 to 162 months, with a median of 20 months. The patients’ ages varied from 18 to 95 years (median age: 60 years old), with a predominance of male patients (64.8%). Table 1 represents the main clinico-demographic features.

According to the pathological analysis, clear cell RCC represented 66.7% of cases, followed by chromophobe RCC (13.7%), and papillary RCC (5.2%). Other subtypes (14.4%) were unclassified, collecting duct carcinoma, Xp11 translocation subtype, and others. Relating to tumor sizes, lesions varied from 1.0 cm to 22.0 cm. Furthermore, 72.3% of renal masses were <7.0 cm.

Regarding locally advanced diseases, we found peri-renal fat invasion in 554 cases (12.3%), renal vein thrombus in 348 cases (7.7%), and inferior vena cava invasion in 176 cases (3.9%). We found lymph node metastasis in 131 cases (2.9%). However, 40.1% of the pathological reports had no information regarding nodal disease (pNx), corresponding to the patients who underwent PN or RN with no lymphadenectomy. Table 2 represents the main pathological data.

At the time of this analysis, 3,259 patients (72.2%) were alive without disease, and 356 (7.6%) had local recurrence. Overall death occurred in 426 patients (7.5%), and 292 (6.5%) had cancer-related death. There was a lack of information for 154 (3.4%) alive patients and 24 (0.5%) dead patients.

The 5-year OS and 10-year OS rates were 86.1% and 69.5%, respectively. The median OS in elderly patients (>60 years) was 99.9 months, which was significantly different from the group between 40 and 59 years old (106.8 months) and those under 40 years old (111.9 months). The 5-year and 10-year CSS rates were 89.9% and 81.8%, respectively, and the median CSS was 109 months (107.8–110.3 months).

In the univariate analysis, OS and CSS were influenced by all the variables except gender, smoking, and non-grouped pN stage (p > 0.05). Age was not a predictor of CSS in the univariate analysis. When grouping pN0 and pNx, there was a significant effect on OS and CSS (Tables 1 and 2).

Multivariate analysis was conducted with factors predicting 10-year OS (Table 3). Demographic and clinical predicting factors were age (HR: 2.978, 95% CI: 2.038–5.269 for elderly people ≥60 years old), anemia (HR: 1.44, 95% CI: 1.17–1.76; p = 0.001), presence of symptoms at presentation (HR: 1.26, 95% CI: 1.02–1.60; p = 0.037), Karnofsky score ≤80 (HR: 2.12, 95% CI: 1.67–2.7; p < 0.001), and ASA score ≥3 (HR: 1.49, 95% CI: 1.19–1.86; p < 0.001). The pathological factors were nodal metastasis (HR: 2.14, 95% CI: 1.5–3.06; p < 0.001), peri-renal fat invasion (HR: 2.12, 95% CI: 1.7–2.65; p < 0.001), inferior vena cava (IVC) invasion (HR: 1.61, 95% CI: 1.15–2.27; p = 0.006), histologic tumoral necrosis (HR: 1.69, 95% CI: 1.21–2.09; p < 0.001), and tumor size >7 cm (HR: 1.64, 95% CI: 1.33–2.09; p < 0.001). The multivariate analysis of CSS, according to the demographic, clinical, and pathological features is described in Table 4.

DISCUSSION

In this study, we included data from 28 institutions in LA and Spain, and thus, this study is a unique initiative that can act as a foundation for future studies on RCC involving this population. Survival rates were notably high in this study (OS: 69.5%; CSS: 81.8%). The OS and CSS in this population were satisfactory and comparable with other international series. Some features that could justify these findings are the percentage of young patients under 60 years old, the increase in the life expectancy around the world, the predominance of patients classified as ASA 2 (68.1%) and ASA 1 (18.5%), and the rise of incidental tumors at the localized stage (76.1% were pT1 or pT2) [15,16]. Nevertheless, the majority of patients had a good performance status. Only 14.9% had a Karnofsky score <80, and less than 8% presented the ECOG score ≥2. Regarding the pathological factors, nodal metastasis and high histological grade (grades III or IV) are adverse factors for OS and CSS [3, 17, 18]. In this series, the high nuclear grade was found in 40% of the cases, and the nodal disease occurred infrequently in only 3%.

Gender was not a significant predictor in our analysis. However, recent studies within the past few decades suggest a better survival rate for women [17, 18]. Recently, for LA patients who underwent minimally invasive surgery, Secin et al. (2017) and Lee et al. (2012) demonstrated that the mortality and local recurrence rates in women are up to four times greater than in men, resulting in a controversy [19, 20].

Age impacts global mortality. However, some studies reported worse CSS related to younger patients [1, 15, 16]. In our univariate and multivariate analysis, age was not a significant predictor (p = 0.067). There are probably no biological differences in RCC among young and elderly patients in the population of our study.

The impact of ethnicity in cancer mortality is controversial. In our series, patients grouped as black or mulatto presented better OS and CSS rates (mean OS = 104.4 months vs. 99.4 months for the others), but this difference was not significant (p = 0.341). This group represented just 2% of the reported cases in our database. In a multi-ethnic population, there are no accurate interpretations to justify this data. Moreover, race information was absent in 36.1% of the cases. Data from the USA show similar rates for Hispanics and non-Hispanics. Black patients in the USA have demonstrated a faster decrease in mortality rates compared to white patients since the 1970s [7].

Nowadays, there is a tendency to offer active surveillance in localized masses for patients with multiple comorbidities (ASA ≥3). Our group previously reported that this feature could be an adverse prognostic factor in RCC. ASA also seems to be associated with tumors with more aggressive pathological features [21]. In our study, ASA score impacted OS and CSS in the univariate analysis. In the multivariate analysis, the ASA score persisted as an independent prognostic factor for 10-year OS and the segments at 36 or 60 months, but not for CSS.

In the literature, anemia can be related to the worst prognosis. The absolute hematocrit level is associated with other factors, such as nutrition and diet, medications in use, external bleeding, hematologic diseases, and genetics [22]. We chose the cut-off point of hemoglobin lower than 10 g/dL. Anemia was considered as an adverse predictor for OS (HR = 1.43) and CSS (HR = 1.45).

Smoking is a recognized risk factor for RCC, but there is no consensus on whether it works as a prognostic factor. In some studies, smoking is associated with worst survival, but this is a controversial issue [23–25]. In this series, former smokers had lower OS and CSS rates, but this was not statistically significant. We were unable to report whether former smokers in this study had a higher tobacco exposure than active smokers. Further efforts will be required to elucidate this issue.

The predominance of renal masses at the initial stages may explain the fact that pT staging was not a significant predictor, even after classifying the stages into two groups (pT1-pT2 and pT3-pT4). The isolate analysis of pT staging is not sufficiently accurate to determine prognosis. Nonetheless, the assumption of tumor size greater than 7 cm as an independent prognostic factor corroborated the findings of other studies [26, 27]. Other factors, such as nuclear grade and node disease are also important. Similar to the results of the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) trial conducted by Blom et al. (2009), we found nodal metastasis in 3% of the cases (vs. 4% in the EORTC trial) [28]. Nowadays, regional lymphadenectomy is not a routine procedure and has no defined templates, particularly in nephron-sparing surgeries. In our series, pN+ cases presented OS and CSS rates around 73% and 75%, respectively. Other series reported rates lower than 30% over five years [1, 3, 29]. Usually, almost 50% of pN+ patients present concomitant distant metastasis. We did not consider patients with distant metastasis, so this fact could have contributed for these better survival rates.

Despite the limitations and recent recommendations about nuclear grade [11], we selected classifications of the low and high nuclear grades. A high nuclear grade evidenced a higher cancer mortality (HR:1.399, 95% CI: 1.090–1.796). However, nuclear grade did not persist as an independent predictor in a truncated analysis at 36 or 60 months (data not shown). The histologic tumoral necrosis increased the global and cancer-specific mortality by 65% to 70%. Intratumoral necrosis was originally described as a prognostic factor for clear cell RCC [30]. In our series, we had a predominance of clear cell RCC, but about one-third of cases with tumoral necrosis had other histologic subtypes. Necrosis can be related to a high cellular proliferation index leading to intratumoral hypoxia. This issue, particularly in non-clear cell subtypes, needs further investigations [31]. In the same way, the sarcomatoid component impacted OS and CSS rates. Of the 2,876 cases available for this information, we found 3% with a sarcomatoid component.

The most important predictor for global and cancer-specific mortality in multivariate analysis was peri-renal fat invasion (HR: 2.121, 95% CI: 1.699–2.647; and HR: 2.107, 95% CI: 1.681–3.579, respectively). If the adipose tissue is involved, the tumor cells are in intimal contact with microvasculature and lymphatics vessels in peri-renal tissue, favoring the metastatic dissemination [32]. The concomitance of fat invasion and other adverse factors, such as high nuclear grade, sarcomatoid component, nodal metastasis, or venous invasion leads to worse survival rates [33, 34]. In some series, peri-renal invasion is not an independent prognostic factor for OS or CSS. In a series from our group with 511 metastatic patients undergone nephrectomy, the peri-renal fact invasion was also an independent prognostic factor for adverse OS and CSS [35]. In our view, this pathologic feature seems to be important and requires more investigations.

The adverse prognostic role of renal sinus invasion occurring isolated or in association with peri-renal fat invasion has been investigated. The renal sinus presents profuse microcirculation close to the hilar and lymphatic vessels [36]. Renal sinus invasion was not studied because this information was not available in many cases of our database.

We found that microvascular invasion (MVI) was an adverse predictor in the univariate and multivariate analysis for OS and CSS. Although this factor has already been demonstrated in previous studies, the ISUP/WHO classification did not require a mandatory description on the pathological reports [11, 37]. MVI is a prognostic factor in other urological malignancies, and its detection can be made by expert pathologists with no significant increase in institutional costs. We believe that this information should be regularly incorporated in pathological reports.

Positive surgical margins (PSM) are considered risk factors for local recurrences, mainly in patients who undergo PN [38, 39]. However, the impact on OS and CSS is debated. In this study, the survival rates were about 10 months lower than those of patients with negative margins. PSM was a significant predictor only in the univariate analysis, which is consistent with the findings reported in the literature.

Interestedly, we detected a high proportion of chromophobe RCC in this population (16%). The literature usually reports a proportion between 6% and 10% [40]. Moreover, the survival rates of chromophobe RCC were better, which is consistent with this histologic subtype. A possible explanation is that these cases could be mistaken as oncocytic renal neoplasms [11].

We can find some limitations in our study. First, this is a retrospective multicentric study with patients treated at different times. It demands efforts from all the involved centers to provide and review reliable data, besides the lack of information of a few variables. Second, there was not a central pathological review (except in Brazilian cases). However, these patients were treated on regional referral centers, and the majority of pathologic evaluations were performed by skilled uro-pathologists reflecting the reality of treatment of RCC in LA tertiary care centers. Anyway, we aim to validate these findings with further central pathology review and future studies from the group. Despite such limitations, we believe that this study contributes to knowledge regarding RCC and brings the opportunity for more deep investigations related to the significant prognostic factors identified in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

This cooperative project aggregated a large, representative RCC database. This database can be a foundation for several other studies in the research area. Our findings agreed with series results from developed countries. The presence of signs and symptoms at presentation, anemia, KPS ≤80, IVC invasion, nodal disease, tumoral necrosis, large tumor size, ASA >3, older adults >60 years old, and peri-renal fat invasion interferes with 10-years OS. Furthermore, symptomatic patients, anemia, ECOG ≥2, KPS ≤80, nodal disease, tumoral necrosis, MVI, high nuclear grade, large tumors, and peri-renal fat invasion are independent prognostic factors for 10-years CSS. We emphasize that ASA and peri-renal fat invasion as prognostic factors deserve further study. Additionally, information regarding MVI should be incorporated in pathological reports.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors have no conflict of interest to report.